A Reddit user reported receiving a Notice of Intent to Deny (NOID) for their EB-1A application, which was submitted under premium processing to the Texas Service Center (TSC). The applicant’s profile is based outside the U.S. and focuses on the consulting industry rather than academia. USCIS acknowledged that the applicant met three of the five required criteria but denied the application on Final Merits, citing insufficient evidence of sustained national or international acclaim.
Key Details:
- USCIS recognized fulfillment of 3 out of 5 criteria: scholarly articles, leading role, and high salary.
- Denial focused on lack of evidence for sustained acclaim and top echelon salary.
- The applicant’s Original Contributions (OC) were not addressed in the NOID.
- The user seeks advice from others who successfully navigated similar NOIDs, particularly regarding the Final Merits evaluation.
This case highlights the challenges faced by applicants with industry-based profiles in the EB-1A category, particularly in demonstrating the required level of acclaim. Need help with your immigration case? Visit QuickFiling.us for professional immigration services.
Source: r/eb_1a